What the NVIDIA Reporting Teaches Companies About Executive Exposure
A person is easier to approach than a system. Where executive exposure builds unnoticed, and the questions every CEO and board should be able to answer.
The recent reporting about NVIDIA's leadership has put a spotlight on a risk that firewalls do not address. The allegations are unproven and investigations are ongoing, so this article takes no position on them. The lesson for any company with valuable technology holds whatever they conclude.
Foreign intelligence services have never needed to breach a network to learn what a company knows. They need a person with access.
Exposure sits with people, not systems
Companies invest heavily in cybersecurity, and they should. But the information that matters most, such as product roadmaps, deal terms, technology and partner arrangements, lives in people's heads and in their relationships. Foreign intelligence services want more than the "what." They want the "so what": why a decision was made, or why it wasn't. That insight sits with the people who have inside access.
I spent more than three decades in intelligence, diplomacy and counterintelligence, then led global safety and security for a Fortune 500 company with more than 25,000 employees across 2,000 locations. The pattern was consistent. A person is easier to approach than a system, and an approach can look entirely ordinary: a friendly introduction, a consulting offer, a flattering invitation, an investor with a strategic interest, a supplier who asks a few extra questions.
Four places exposure builds unnoticed
None of these is evidence of wrongdoing. They are the places where exposure can grow without anyone deciding to let it.
- Leaders and their relationships. Undisclosed ties, outside business interests, financial entanglements and personal vulnerabilities all matter more as a leader's access and authority grow.
- Insiders. Employees with access who feel overlooked, are under financial pressure or are about to leave. Departures deserve as much attention as hires.
- Partners and investors. Foreign investors, joint ventures and licensing deals bring access along with capital. Terms are reviewed closely; the people behind them often are not.
- Suppliers and acquisitions. Vendors with access to facilities or data, and acquired companies that bring their own people and legacy relationships.
Three questions every CEO and board should be able to answer
Most companies can answer the first. Very few can answer all three.
- Do we know who has access to our most valuable information, and why? Access tends to accumulate over time and rarely gets reviewed against what people actually need.
- Have we assessed our leaders' and key partners' exposure, with counsel involved, before someone else does? An independent look is easier to do before a problem than after one.
- If an employee or partner is approached, do they know what to do and who to tell? The first report is often the most valuable one, and it only happens if people know it is safe to make.
Doing it properly
This kind of work touches people's professional and sometimes private lives, so how it is done matters as much as what it finds. It should be directed by counsel or the board, limited to a defined scope, proportionate to the risk and consistent with employment and privacy law. The aim is to find and reduce exposure, not to surveil anyone.
It also benefits from independence. Someone outside the company's internal politics can ask the questions that insiders cannot comfortably ask of colleagues.
What to do this quarter
You do not need a large program to start. Four steps are enough to see where you stand.
- Map who has access to your most sensitive information, and confirm each person still needs it.
- Review your five most significant outside relationships: partners, investors, key suppliers and any recent acquisitions.
- Brief leaders and key staff on what an approach looks like and who to tell.
- Ask an independent expert to test the assumptions behind the first three.
Companies that do this well are not the ones with the biggest budgets. They are the ones that asked the questions before they had to.
Benjamin House is the Founder and Principal of Veritas Intelligence, an Orlando-based executive intelligence and risk advisory firm. He is a retired CIA Senior Operations Officer, a two-time CIA Chief of Station and a former Army Counterintelligence Special Agent.
Require intelligence support related to this topic? Contact Veritas Intelligence for a confidential, no-obligation consultation.
